Most Similar Ingredients

Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Black is the closest alternative to Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal. Based on our ingredient comparison method, this product shares 82% of its ingredients with the original — making it a great match in terms of formulation.

Most Similar Ingredients

Ulta Beauty Automatic Eyeliner Chocolate Metallic is the closest alternative to Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal. Based on our ingredient comparison method, this product shares 82% of its ingredients with the original — making it a great match in terms of formulation.

Most Similar Ingredients

Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Black Brown is the closest alternative to Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal. Based on our ingredient comparison method, this product shares 82% of its ingredients with the original — making it a great match in terms of formulation.

6 Dupes Found for Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal

Dupe Version #1: Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Black

Dupe Version
Original Version
Match Rate 82%

A strong dupe for Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal, sharing key ingredients and formulation traits.

Dupe Explanation

Both products are in the Eye Liner category and share 12 common ingredients.

They are also similar in formulation traits: both are Paraben free, Sulfate free, Alcohol free and EU Allergent Free — making them suitable for sensitive or ingredient-conscious users

Both products have the effects of Cleansing, Anti Aging, UV Protection

Find comparison information with Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Black

Looking for a full analysis of similarities and differences between these two products?

Want to dive deeper? Compare it with Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal to explore ingredient differences and potential skin compatibility.

Dupe Version #2: Ulta Beauty Automatic Eyeliner Chocolate Metallic

Dupe Version
Original Version
Match Rate 82%

A strong dupe for Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal, sharing key ingredients and formulation traits.

Dupe Explanation

Both products are in the Eye Liner category and share 12 common ingredients.

They are also similar in formulation traits: both are Paraben free, Sulfate free, Alcohol free and EU Allergent Free — making them suitable for sensitive or ingredient-conscious users

Both products have the effects of Cleansing, Anti Aging, UV Protection

Find comparison information with Ulta Beauty Automatic Eyeliner Chocolate Metallic

Looking for a full analysis of similarities and differences between these two products?

Want to dive deeper? Compare it with Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal to explore ingredient differences and potential skin compatibility.

Dupe Version #3: Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Black Brown

Dupe Version
Original Version
Match Rate 82%

A strong dupe for Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal, sharing key ingredients and formulation traits.

Dupe Explanation

Both products are in the Eye Liner category and share 12 common ingredients.

They are also similar in formulation traits: both are Paraben free, Sulfate free, Alcohol free and EU Allergent Free — making them suitable for sensitive or ingredient-conscious users

Both products have the effects of Cleansing, Anti Aging, UV Protection

Find comparison information with Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Black Brown

Looking for a full analysis of similarities and differences between these two products?

Want to dive deeper? Compare it with Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal to explore ingredient differences and potential skin compatibility.

Dupe Version #4: Honest Beauty Vibeliner Pencil Eyeliner

Dupe Version
Original Version
Match Rate 72%

A strong dupe for Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal, sharing key ingredients and formulation traits.

Dupe Explanation

Both products are in the Eye Liner category and share 5 common ingredients.

They are also similar in formulation traits: both are Paraben free, Sulfate free, Alcohol free and EU Allergent Free — making them suitable for sensitive or ingredient-conscious users

Both products have the effects of Cleansing, Anti Aging, UV Protection

Find comparison information with Honest Beauty Vibeliner Pencil Eyeliner

Looking for a full analysis of similarities and differences between these two products?

Want to dive deeper? Compare it with Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal to explore ingredient differences and potential skin compatibility.

Dupe Version #5: Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner 1410 Midnight Gray

Dupe Version
Original Version
Match Rate 72%

A strong dupe for Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal, sharing key ingredients and formulation traits.

Dupe Explanation

Both products are in the Eye Liner category and share 5 common ingredients.

They are also similar in formulation traits: both are Paraben free, Sulfate free, Alcohol free and EU Allergent Free — making them suitable for sensitive or ingredient-conscious users

Both products have the effects of Cleansing, Anti Aging, UV Protection

Find comparison information with Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner 1410 Midnight Gray

Looking for a full analysis of similarities and differences between these two products?

Want to dive deeper? Compare it with Ulta Beauty Automatic Eye Liner Matte Charcoal to explore ingredient differences and potential skin compatibility.